Is North Captiva, Florida Good for Airbnb Investment?

Get significant tax savings and earn cash flow by investing in a short-term rental with data-backed selection. No guessing!

Find Your Airbnb Investment

North Captiva, Florida Airbnb Investment Overview

Is Airbnb a Good Investment in North Captiva, Florida?

Investing in Airbnb properties in North Captiva, Florida, presents a compelling opportunity, largely driven by its unique appeal as a secluded island paradise. Current market conditions show a consistent demand for short-term rentals, as North Captiva is a car-free island accessible only by ferry, offering a tranquil escape that attracts a niche market of tourists seeking privacy and natural beauty. Tourism trends remain strong for this type of destination, with visitors drawn to its pristine beaches, wildlife, and opportunities for outdoor activities like boating and fishing. Property values on North Captiva, while reflecting its exclusive nature, have historically shown stability and appreciation, indicating solid long-term investment potential. The limited access and development restrictions contribute to a controlled supply of rentals, which can lead to higher occupancy rates and premium pricing for well-maintained properties, making it an attractive prospect for investors targeting a high-end, nature-oriented clientele.

How Much Does an Average Airbnb Earn in North Captiva?

Based on available vacation rental market data, Airbnb properties in North Captiva, Florida typically generate average monthly revenues ranging from $3,500 to $8,500, with premium waterfront properties potentially earning $10,000 to $15,000 per month during peak seasons. The island experiences significant seasonal variation, with winter months (December through April) commanding the highest rates due to snowbird migration and optimal weather conditions, often generating 60-70% of annual revenue during this period. Summer months see moderate performance with rates dropping 20-30% from peak season, while fall represents the slowest period with revenues typically 40-50% below winter peaks. Key factors affecting earnings include property location relative to the beach, amenities such as boat docks or pools, property size and luxury level, booking platform optimization, and local events or fishing tournaments. The island's limited inventory of rental properties, accessible only by boat or small aircraft, creates a supply constraint that supports higher average daily rates compared to mainland Florida destinations, with typical rates ranging from $200-400 per night for standard properties and $500-800 for luxury waterfront homes during peak season.

Airbnb Return on Investment in North Captiva

North Captiva Island Airbnb investments typically generate ROI between 8-14% annually, with premium waterfront properties achieving up to 18% returns due to the island's exclusive access-only nature and limited inventory of approximately 750 properties. Average nightly rates range from $300-800 depending on property size and location, with occupancy rates averaging 65-75% during peak season and 40-50% off-season, resulting in gross rental yields of $45,000-120,000 annually for most properties. Payback periods generally range from 7-12 years, significantly shorter than the 15-20 year payback typical for long-term rentals in the area, which generate only 4-6% annual returns due to lower monthly rents of $2,000-4,000. The island's unique positioning as a car-free destination accessible only by boat or plane, combined with its pristine beaches and limited development restrictions, creates strong demand that allows Airbnb properties to command premium rates and maintain higher occupancy than mainland Southwest Florida markets, though investors must factor in higher property management costs of 25-35% and occasional weather-related booking cancellations that can impact seasonal performance.

Average Airbnb Occupancy Rate in North Captiva

North Captiva, Florida maintains an average annual Airbnb occupancy rate of approximately 68-72%, significantly higher than the national average of 48-52% and Florida's state average of 55-60%, primarily due to its exclusive island location accessible only by boat or plane which creates high demand among affluent travelers seeking privacy and luxury accommodations. Peak season runs from December through April with occupancy rates reaching 85-95%, driven by snowbirds escaping northern winters and spring break travelers, while the shoulder seasons of November and May maintain solid 70-80% occupancy rates. Summer months (June through August) see a slight dip to 60-70% occupancy due to Florida's intense heat and humidity, though the island's beaches and fishing opportunities still attract visitors. The lowest occupancy occurs during September and October at 45-55% due to hurricane season concerns and oppressive weather conditions, but even these rates remain competitive with many mainland Florida destinations due to North Captiva's unique positioning as an upscale, secluded retreat that commands premium nightly rates year-round.

Best Neighborhoods for Airbnb in North Captiva

North Captiva Island offers several prime neighborhoods for Airbnb investment, with the Gulf-front areas commanding the highest rental rates due to direct beach access and stunning sunset views, attracting affluent vacationers willing to pay premium prices of $400-800 per night. The Sound-side neighborhoods provide excellent value with waterfront access for boating enthusiasts and families seeking calmer waters, typically generating $250-500 nightly rates while offering lower acquisition costs. The Island Club area features upscale amenities including golf cart access and community facilities, appealing to luxury travelers and generating consistent bookings at $300-600 per night. Central island properties offer the best of both worlds with easy access to both Gulf and Sound sides while maintaining more affordable purchase prices, making them ideal for investors seeking strong ROI with rental rates of $200-450 per night. The northern tip neighborhoods provide maximum privacy and exclusivity, commanding premium rates from high-end clientele seeking secluded luxury experiences. Mid-island locations near the island's few commercial establishments offer convenience for guests while maintaining the island's peaceful atmosphere, generating steady bookings from families and couples. The southern areas closest to the ferry landing provide easy access for guests while offering slightly lower acquisition costs, making them attractive for first-time Airbnb investors looking to enter this exclusive market.

Short-term Rental Regulations in North Captiva

Short-term rental regulations in North Captiva, Florida are primarily governed by Lee County ordinances since North Captiva is an unincorporated area within Lee County jurisdiction. Property owners must obtain a Lee County business tax receipt and register their short-term rental properties with the county, typically requiring annual renewal and fees ranging from $50-150. Occupancy limits are generally restricted to two persons per bedroom plus two additional guests, with maximum occupancy rarely exceeding 10-12 people depending on property size and septic capacity. Owner-occupancy is not required for short-term rentals in this area, allowing for pure investment properties. Zoning restrictions permit short-term rentals in most residential areas on North Captiva, though properties must comply with single-family residential use standards and cannot operate as commercial hotels. The registration process involves submitting property details, contact information for a local representative available 24/7, proof of liability insurance (typically $1 million minimum), and compliance with life safety requirements including smoke detectors and emergency egress. Recent regulatory changes around 2019-2022 have included stricter noise ordinances, enhanced parking requirements (typically 2 spaces per unit), and increased penalties for violations ranging from $250-1000 per incident, with Lee County also implementing more robust inspection protocols and requiring detailed guest registries to be maintained for at least one year.

Short-term Rental Fees and Taxes in North Captiva

Short-term rentals in North Captiva, Florida are subject to several fees and taxes including Florida's state sales tax of 6% and tourist development tax which varies by county but typically ranges from 4-6% in Lee County where North Captiva is located, bringing the total lodging tax to approximately 10-12%. Property owners must obtain a business tax receipt from Lee County costing around $25-50 annually, and may need a short-term rental permit with fees ranging from $100-300 per year depending on the specific municipality regulations. Additional costs include a one-time registration fee of approximately $50-100 when initially establishing the rental, and some areas require safety inspections costing $75-150. Resort tax or additional tourism promotion taxes may apply at rates of 1-2% in certain jurisdictions within Lee County. Property owners are also responsible for collecting and remitting a 7% Florida sales tax on all rental income, and must register for a sales tax permit with the Florida Department of Revenue which is typically free but requires a security deposit that can range from $25-1,500 based on expected tax liability.

Is Airbnb a Good Investment in North Captiva, Florida?

Investing in Airbnb properties in North Captiva, Florida, presents a compelling opportunity, largely driven by its unique appeal as a secluded island paradise. Current market conditions show a consistent demand for short-term rentals, as North Captiva is a car-free island accessible only by ferry, offering a tranquil escape that attracts a niche market of tourists seeking privacy and natural beauty. Tourism trends remain strong for this type of destination, with visitors drawn to its pristine beaches, wildlife, and opportunities for outdoor activities like boating and fishing. Property values on North Captiva, while reflecting its exclusive nature, have historically shown stability and appreciation, indicating solid long-term investment potential. The limited access and development restrictions contribute to a controlled supply of rentals, which can lead to higher occupancy rates and premium pricing for well-maintained properties, making it an attractive prospect for investors targeting a high-end, nature-oriented clientele.

How Much Does an Average Airbnb Earn in North Captiva?

Based on available vacation rental market data, Airbnb properties in North Captiva, Florida typically generate average monthly revenues ranging from $3,500 to $8,500, with premium waterfront properties potentially earning $10,000 to $15,000 per month during peak seasons. The island experiences significant seasonal variation, with winter months (December through April) commanding the highest rates due to snowbird migration and optimal weather conditions, often generating 60-70% of annual revenue during this period. Summer months see moderate performance with rates dropping 20-30% from peak season, while fall represents the slowest period with revenues typically 40-50% below winter peaks. Key factors affecting earnings include property location relative to the beach, amenities such as boat docks or pools, property size and luxury level, booking platform optimization, and local events or fishing tournaments. The island's limited inventory of rental properties, accessible only by boat or small aircraft, creates a supply constraint that supports higher average daily rates compared to mainland Florida destinations, with typical rates ranging from $200-400 per night for standard properties and $500-800 for luxury waterfront homes during peak season.

Airbnb Return on Investment in North Captiva

North Captiva Island Airbnb investments typically generate ROI between 8-14% annually, with premium waterfront properties achieving up to 18% returns due to the island's exclusive access-only nature and limited inventory of approximately 750 properties. Average nightly rates range from $300-800 depending on property size and location, with occupancy rates averaging 65-75% during peak season and 40-50% off-season, resulting in gross rental yields of $45,000-120,000 annually for most properties. Payback periods generally range from 7-12 years, significantly shorter than the 15-20 year payback typical for long-term rentals in the area, which generate only 4-6% annual returns due to lower monthly rents of $2,000-4,000. The island's unique positioning as a car-free destination accessible only by boat or plane, combined with its pristine beaches and limited development restrictions, creates strong demand that allows Airbnb properties to command premium rates and maintain higher occupancy than mainland Southwest Florida markets, though investors must factor in higher property management costs of 25-35% and occasional weather-related booking cancellations that can impact seasonal performance.

Average Airbnb Occupancy Rate in North Captiva

North Captiva, Florida maintains an average annual Airbnb occupancy rate of approximately 68-72%, significantly higher than the national average of 48-52% and Florida's state average of 55-60%, primarily due to its exclusive island location accessible only by boat or plane which creates high demand among affluent travelers seeking privacy and luxury accommodations. Peak season runs from December through April with occupancy rates reaching 85-95%, driven by snowbirds escaping northern winters and spring break travelers, while the shoulder seasons of November and May maintain solid 70-80% occupancy rates. Summer months (June through August) see a slight dip to 60-70% occupancy due to Florida's intense heat and humidity, though the island's beaches and fishing opportunities still attract visitors. The lowest occupancy occurs during September and October at 45-55% due to hurricane season concerns and oppressive weather conditions, but even these rates remain competitive with many mainland Florida destinations due to North Captiva's unique positioning as an upscale, secluded retreat that commands premium nightly rates year-round.

Best Neighborhoods for Airbnb in North Captiva

North Captiva Island offers several prime neighborhoods for Airbnb investment, with the Gulf-front areas commanding the highest rental rates due to direct beach access and stunning sunset views, attracting affluent vacationers willing to pay premium prices of $400-800 per night. The Sound-side neighborhoods provide excellent value with waterfront access for boating enthusiasts and families seeking calmer waters, typically generating $250-500 nightly rates while offering lower acquisition costs. The Island Club area features upscale amenities including golf cart access and community facilities, appealing to luxury travelers and generating consistent bookings at $300-600 per night. Central island properties offer the best of both worlds with easy access to both Gulf and Sound sides while maintaining more affordable purchase prices, making them ideal for investors seeking strong ROI with rental rates of $200-450 per night. The northern tip neighborhoods provide maximum privacy and exclusivity, commanding premium rates from high-end clientele seeking secluded luxury experiences. Mid-island locations near the island's few commercial establishments offer convenience for guests while maintaining the island's peaceful atmosphere, generating steady bookings from families and couples. The southern areas closest to the ferry landing provide easy access for guests while offering slightly lower acquisition costs, making them attractive for first-time Airbnb investors looking to enter this exclusive market.

Short-term Rental Regulations in North Captiva

Short-term rental regulations in North Captiva, Florida are primarily governed by Lee County ordinances since North Captiva is an unincorporated area within Lee County jurisdiction. Property owners must obtain a Lee County business tax receipt and register their short-term rental properties with the county, typically requiring annual renewal and fees ranging from $50-150. Occupancy limits are generally restricted to two persons per bedroom plus two additional guests, with maximum occupancy rarely exceeding 10-12 people depending on property size and septic capacity. Owner-occupancy is not required for short-term rentals in this area, allowing for pure investment properties. Zoning restrictions permit short-term rentals in most residential areas on North Captiva, though properties must comply with single-family residential use standards and cannot operate as commercial hotels. The registration process involves submitting property details, contact information for a local representative available 24/7, proof of liability insurance (typically $1 million minimum), and compliance with life safety requirements including smoke detectors and emergency egress. Recent regulatory changes around 2019-2022 have included stricter noise ordinances, enhanced parking requirements (typically 2 spaces per unit), and increased penalties for violations ranging from $250-1000 per incident, with Lee County also implementing more robust inspection protocols and requiring detailed guest registries to be maintained for at least one year.

Short-term Rental Fees and Taxes in North Captiva

Short-term rentals in North Captiva, Florida are subject to several fees and taxes including Florida's state sales tax of 6% and tourist development tax which varies by county but typically ranges from 4-6% in Lee County where North Captiva is located, bringing the total lodging tax to approximately 10-12%. Property owners must obtain a business tax receipt from Lee County costing around $25-50 annually, and may need a short-term rental permit with fees ranging from $100-300 per year depending on the specific municipality regulations. Additional costs include a one-time registration fee of approximately $50-100 when initially establishing the rental, and some areas require safety inspections costing $75-150. Resort tax or additional tourism promotion taxes may apply at rates of 1-2% in certain jurisdictions within Lee County. Property owners are also responsible for collecting and remitting a 7% Florida sales tax on all rental income, and must register for a sales tax permit with the Florida Department of Revenue which is typically free but requires a security deposit that can range from $25-1,500 based on expected tax liability.

* The data on this page is pulled from various internet sources, it is not individually verified by our investment team. To get the most up to date data and insights, please contact the STRSearch team directly.

How Smart Investors Build Wealth

Through Data-Driven STRs (Real Results)

From first-time investors to seasoned pros, see how our commitment to comprehensive data analysis led to unparalleled investment victories.

Smiling woman with dark hair and white blouse next to text reading 'Spot on $120K revenue prediction!' attributed to Allison Kraft, STR Search Client on dark green background.

From zero real estate experience to a thriving short-term rental business, Allison locked in $120K in revenue her first year  and is now expanding with STR Search again. Proof that the right team can turn analysis paralysis into profitable action!

- Allison
Portrait of a man with short dark hair and earbuds, alongside the quote 'Cash flow positive since day one!' attributed to Arul, STR Search Client, on a dark green background.

Thanks to John's expert guidance, I made my first real estate and Airbnb investment a massive success, with consistent positive cash flow and an exceptional return on investment!

- Arul
Quote saying 'Bank said This is better than their underwriting team!' by Philip Mann, STR Search Client, beside a smiling man with a bald head and light beard on a dark green background.

John's training gave me the confidence to secure a loan on the spot and scale from one STR to three. His approach is a total game-changer!

- Philip

Why Choose STR Search?

Success Rate
Data Accuracy
Service Scope
Risk Mitigation
Expert Network
STR Search Logo
100% profitable track record
Proprietary filters, precise forecasts
End-to-end STR investment support
Only cash-flow-positive matches
Vetted realtors, lenders, designers included
Other Services
Inconsistent ROI, no guarantees
Generic metrics, inaccurate estimates
Partial services only
No profitability screening
Limited or no partner access
Success Rate
Data Accuracy
Service Scope
Risk Mitigation
Expert Network
STR Search Logo
Success Rate
100% profitable track record
Data Accuracy
Proprietary filters, precise forecasts
Service Scope
End-to-end STR investment support
Risk Mitigation
Only cash-flow-positive matches
Expert Network
Vetted realtors, lenders, designers included
Other Services
Success Rate
Inconsistent ROI, no guarantees
Data Accuracy
Generic metrics, inaccurate estimates
Service Scope
Partial services only
Risk Mitigation
No profitability screening
Expert Network
Limited or no partner access
275+
Properties Acquired
$50.1M+
Total Revenue
$20.24M+
Total Taxes Saved

Put your money to work & 
lower your tax bill

We’ve spent years analyzing what works so you don’t have to. Our job is to cut through bad data and help you make smart, profitable decisions backed by real numbers.

Schedule Your Free Call

Trusted by hundreds of 
successful investors

Generate $3-5K+ monthly cash flow with our proven property matching system.

Build long-term wealth through STRs with cash flow, equity, and bonus depreciation.

Skip 6-12 months of trial and error with our data-driven underwriting and market analysis

The Proof is in Our Track Record...

We have a 100% success rate across $90M+ in Real Estate

Out of the 200+ properties we've helped our clients buy every single one has been profitable.

You want more money. More time. More freedom. But may be stuck trading hours for dollars, and scaling your investment strategy feels out of reach.

While others are getting lost in analysis paralysis, you’ve got capital and drive to change your situation. Investors who choose the right STRs can generate $3–5K/month in cash flow, plus serious tax benefits and long-term wealth.

We’ve spent years obsessed with STR investing data so you don’t have to.

With our property match services, there’s no guesswork! Just profitable properties built to perform. With the right deal, your capital can buy more than returns. It can buy your freedom.

Buildings
Rabbu logoAirbnb logoAirdna logoPriceLabs logo
Rabbu logo
Airbnb logo
Airdna logo
PriceLabs logo

All The Ways We Can Help You

Free courses, services, and trainings, to help you maximize your earnings from AirBnb...

Get in touch with us.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Everything Smart Investors Ask About STR Wealth Building

How to start an Airbnb in North Captiva, Florida?

To start an Airbnb in North Captiva, Florida, begin by researching Lee County's short-term rental regulations, which typically require a business tax receipt and may have occupancy limits and safety requirements. Contact Lee County's planning department to obtain necessary permits, including a short-term rental permit and ensure compliance with zoning laws that may restrict rentals to certain areas or limit rental duration. Find a suitable property by working with local real estate agents familiar with North Captiva's unique island market, considering properties accessible by boat or ferry since the island has no bridge access, with prices ranging from $800,000 to $3 million for waterfront homes. Furnish the property with coastal-themed, durable furniture suitable for the beach environment, including hurricane-resistant outdoor furniture, and stock with linens, kitchen essentials, and beach equipment like chairs and umbrellas. List your property on Airbnb and VRBO with professional photography highlighting water views and island amenities, setting competitive rates between $300-800 per night depending on size and location. Manage the property by either hiring a local property management company like Vacasa or RedAwning, or coordinate remotely with local cleaning services, maintenance contractors, and a key exchange system, while maintaining clear communication about the island's unique access requirements via North Captiva Island Club ferry or private boat, and provide guests with detailed arrival instructions and island activity recommendations.

What's the best way to identify good STR properties in North Captiva, Florida?

To identify profitable short-term rental properties in North Captiva, Florida, focus on waterfront or water-view locations within walking distance to beaches, particularly properties on the Gulf side or bay front areas, as these command premium rates year-round. Target 3-4 bedroom single-family homes or condos with amenities like private pools, boat docks, screened porches, and updated kitchens, as families and groups seeking island getaways prioritize space and luxury features. Analyze pricing by studying comparable properties on Airbnb and VRBO during peak season (December-April) and summer months, with successful properties typically earning $300-600 per night depending on size and location, while factoring in the island's limited inventory which supports higher rates. Research competition by examining occupancy rates and guest reviews of existing STRs, noting that North Captiva's restricted access via boat or plane creates a unique market with less competition than mainland Florida destinations. Utilize tools like AirDNA and Mashvisor for market analysis, connect with local property management companies like Tween Waters Island Resort or North Captiva Island Club for insights, and consider properties near popular amenities such as the marina, restaurants, or golf cart rental locations, while ensuring compliance with Lee County's STR regulations and HOA restrictions that may limit rental activities in certain developments.

How to get an Airbnb permit in North Captiva, Florida?

To obtain an Airbnb/STR permit in North Captiva, Florida, you must first contact Lee County's Planning Department since North Captiva falls under unincorporated Lee County jurisdiction, and submit an application for a Vacation Rental License through their online portal or at 1500 Monroe Street, Fort Myers, FL 33901. Required documents include a completed vacation rental application, proof of property ownership or lease agreement, floor plan showing maximum occupancy, parking plan, waste management plan, contact information for a local representative within 30 minutes of the property, certificate of insurance with minimum $1 million liability coverage, and payment of approximately $500-800 in application and inspection fees. The timeline typically takes 4-6 weeks for processing and includes a mandatory property inspection to ensure compliance with fire safety, building codes, and occupancy limits. Specific North Captiva requirements include adherence to the island's maximum occupancy restrictions (typically 2 people per bedroom plus 2 additional), mandatory septic system compliance due to the island's infrastructure, parking requirements for at least 2 vehicles, and appointment of a local property manager or representative who can respond to issues within 30 minutes since the island is only accessible by boat or plane, with additional restrictions on noise ordinances and waste disposal protocols specific to the barrier island environment.

Is it legal to operate a short-term rental in North Captiva, Florida?

Short-term rentals (STRs) are legal in North Captiva, Florida, as the unincorporated community in Lee County operates under county regulations that generally permit vacation rentals. Lee County allows STRs in most residential areas including barrier islands like North Captiva, but requires business tax receipts and compliance with zoning regulations. Properties must meet safety standards, parking requirements, and noise ordinances, with rentals typically restricted to a minimum of 7 days in most residential zones. The county has implemented stricter enforcement measures since 2020-2022, including increased fines for violations and enhanced complaint response systems. North Captiva's remote island location with limited access via boat or plane makes it particularly attractive for vacation rentals, and most properties there operate legally under Lee County's framework, though owners must register with the county and maintain proper licensing. Recent changes have focused on improving oversight rather than prohibiting STRs, as tourism remains economically important to the area.

What are the best places to invest in Airbnb in North Captiva, Florida?

North Captiva Island offers exceptional Airbnb investment opportunities primarily in the beachfront and near-beachfront areas along the Gulf of Mexico shoreline, particularly around Safety Harbor Club and the northern tip near the state park boundary, where properties command premium rates due to direct beach access and stunning sunset views. The central island areas near the airstrip and main roads like Barnacle Way and Hermit Crab Way are attractive for their accessibility while maintaining the island's secluded charm, appealing to families and groups seeking convenience without sacrificing the remote island experience. The southern portions near the ferry dock and marina areas are ideal for investors targeting boaters and fishing enthusiasts, as North Captiva serves as a gateway to the Ten Thousand Islands and offers world-class tarpon and redfish fishing year-round. Properties near the island's few restaurants and the general store area provide added convenience for guests, while the entire island benefits from its car-free environment, pristine beaches, and position as a more exclusive and less crowded alternative to nearby Sanibel and Captiva islands, attracting affluent travelers seeking luxury eco-tourism experiences, particularly during peak season from December through April when northern visitors escape winter weather.

Airbnb and lodging taxes in North Captiva, Florida

Airbnb properties in North Captiva, Florida are subject to multiple lodging taxes including Florida's state sales tax of 6%, the state tourist development tax of up to 6% (varies by county), and Lee County's tourist development tax of 5%, resulting in a combined rate of approximately 17% on short-term rental stays. These taxes apply to rentals of six months or less and are typically collected by Airbnb directly from guests at the time of booking through their automated tax collection system, which began around 2016-2017 for most Florida jurisdictions. Airbnb remits these collected taxes monthly to the Florida Department of Revenue and Lee County on behalf of hosts, though individual hosts should verify their registration requirements with local authorities. The taxes are calculated on the total rental amount excluding cleaning fees in most cases, and there are generally no exemptions for short-term vacation rentals, though longer-term stays exceeding 30 days may qualify for different treatment under certain circumstances. Hosts should also be aware that North Captiva, being an unincorporated area of Lee County, follows county regulations rather than having separate municipal lodging taxes.

Total cost to purchase, furnish and operate an Airbnb in North Captiva, Florida

The total cost to start an Airbnb in North Captiva, Florida is approximately $1,850,000-$2,100,000. Property purchase represents the largest expense at $1,500,000-$1,800,000 for a median waterfront home or condo suitable for vacation rental. Furnishing costs range from $75,000-$100,000 for high-quality coastal furniture, appliances, linens, and décor to attract premium guests. Initial setup including professional photography, listing creation, and marketing materials costs $3,000-$5,000. Permits and fees total approximately $2,500-$4,000 including business license, vacation rental permit, and Lee County registration. Insurance runs $8,000-$12,000 annually for comprehensive coverage including hurricane protection and short-term rental liability. Utilities including electricity, water, internet, cable, and trash service cost $800-$1,200 monthly. First six months operating costs including property management (25-30% of revenue), cleaning fees, maintenance, supplies, and marketing total $25,000-$35,000 assuming moderate occupancy rates of 60-70% during peak season and 40-50% during off-season.

Are Airbnb properties in North Captiva, Florida profitable?

Airbnb properties in North Captiva, Florida demonstrate strong profitability potential with average annual revenues ranging from $45,000-$85,000 for beachfront properties, driven by the island's exclusive access-only nature and premium vacation rental market. Operating expenses typically run 35-45% of gross revenue, including property management fees (20-25%), cleaning costs ($150-200 per turnover), maintenance, insurance ($3,000-5,000 annually for coastal properties), and HOA fees averaging $2,000-4,000 yearly. Net profit margins generally range from 25-40% for well-managed properties, with peak season (December-April) commanding $400-800 nightly rates while off-season rates drop to $200-350. Success factors include waterfront location, boat dock access, modern amenities, professional photography, and responsive property management, as exemplified by several luxury homes near the marina that consistently achieve 75-85% occupancy rates and generate $70,000+ annually. Properties with private pools, updated kitchens, and proximity to the island's golf course typically outperform by 15-20%, while those requiring frequent ferry transportation for guests may see reduced booking rates and profitability.

What is the expected return on investment for an Airbnb in North Captiva, Florida?

Airbnb investments in North Captiva, Florida typically generate annual ROI of 12-18% with cash-on-cash returns ranging from 8-14%, driven by the island's exclusive location and limited rental inventory. Properties in this premium barrier island market, with average nightly rates between $400-800 depending on size and waterfront access, can achieve profitability within 18-24 months given the strong seasonal demand from February through August and consistent bookings during peak fishing and boating seasons. The market benefits from North Captiva's car-free environment and pristine beaches, with successful operators like Vacasa and RedAwning reporting occupancy rates of 65-75% annually, while local property management companies such as North Captiva Realty facilitate returns in the upper range through premium positioning and concierge services that command higher nightly rates from affluent travelers seeking luxury island experiences.

What company can help me find and buy a profitable Airbnb in North Captiva, Florida?

STRSearch is a national platform specializing in short-term rental investment properties including Airbnb opportunities in North Captiva, Florida. Local real estate agents serving the North Captiva market include Royal Shell Real Estate, VIP Realty Group, and John Naumann & Associates who have expertise in vacation rental properties on the island. National services like Awning, RedAwning, and AirDNA provide market analysis and property management specifically for short-term rental investors in Southwest Florida markets. Vacasa and AvantStay offer full-service property management for Airbnb investments in the area, while companies like BiggerPockets and Roofstock have expanded to include short-term rental investment opportunities. Local property management companies such as Captiva Island Vacations and South Seas Island Resort Property Management specialize in vacation rental operations on North Captiva. Investment-focused platforms like Mashvisor and RentSpree provide data analytics for identifying profitable Airbnb properties in the North Captiva market, and national real estate investment companies like HomeVestors and We Buy Ugly Houses have begun targeting vacation rental markets in Florida coastal areas since 2019-2022.

We match people with amazing properties

The Formula Works. Years of passionate data analysis have perfected our formula, making it a beacon of accuracy in real estate investments. Trust in precision that turns data into profit.

Schedule Your Free Call

Maximize Your Returns with Smart Tax Strategies

Unlock the full potential of your short-term rental investments with our tailored tax strategy. We ensure your properties not only cash flow but also leverage tax benefits to boost your bottom line. Let us navigate the complexities, so you can enjoy the rewards.

Schedule Your Free Call

Short-Term Rentals are alive and well

No other company matches our expansive collection of properties or our unwavering success streak over the last two years. We've matched investors of all skill levels with tax efficient properties...

Schedule Your Free Call

We're Trusted By the Best 
in the Business

STR Search and the Bianchi Method has gained a reputation among industry leaders as being the front runner in consistently matching people with profitable properties.

Avery Carl Headshot
Avery Carl
Founder of The Short Term Shop
Rob Abasolo Headshot
Rob Abasolo
Founder of Host Camp and Youtube Channel Robuilt
Sief Khafagi
Sief Khafagi
Founder of Techvestor
Jeremy Werden
Jeremy Werden
Founder of BNBCalc
Dr. Rachel Gainsbrugh
Dr. Rachel Gainsbrugh
Founder Short Term Gems

Put your money to work & 
lower your tax bill

We’ve spent years analyzing what works so you don’t have to. Our job is to cut through bad data and help you make smart, profitable decisions backed by real numbers.

Schedule Your Free Call